Lightstalkers
* My Profile My Galleries My Networks

McCain in Waziristan?

For those who watched the presidential debates last night – I’m curious about McCain’s assertions (twice) that he’s visited Waziristan. He also described Pakistan as a “failed state” and called its new president “Kadari”, so perhaps he’s a bit spotty on his details – but perhaps someone out there has more knowledge about this claim?

by teru kuwayama at Sat Sep 27 14:56:42 UTC 2008 Al-Madrassa, NYC, United States | Bookmark |

well that was really funny…. Perhaps Palin can do better as she is lives close to russia (in winter can even walk there…. )… she understand a better geopolitics hopefully…
d

by Daniele Mattioli | 27 Sep 2008 15:09 | Shanghai , China |
Don’t forget that he made assertions that we need to properly train interrogators so we don’t torture again…meaning he just admitted we tortured before?

by Brian C Frank | 27 Sep 2008 15:09 | Des Moines, Iowa, United States |
It’s hard to imaging McCain’s motorcade taking in the tourist sites in Waziristan.

by Thorne Anderson | 27 Sep 2008 16:09 | Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States |
Hi Teru,

I shouted out “fact check!” when he asserted that.
Yes, and I wonder if Nawaz Sharif considered his
country as failed when Musharraf staged a coup.
Perhaps he travelled in a kevlar bubble.

But, hey, it played well in Barstow, Waco and
at the Palin house and that is who he was aiming
for with those comments. So bull’s eye!

Cheers,

James.

by James Whitlow Delano | 27 Sep 2008 17:09 | Tokyo, Japan |
You can see Afghanistan from Waziristan!

by Ramin Talaie | 01 Oct 2008 01:10 | Brooklyn, United States |
You can see North Korea quite well from South Korea, but
that is not the same thing as being in it. No better yet,
I can declare in McCain fashion that I have actually stood
in North Korea (inside the silly room in Panmunjom where
DPRK soldiers will declare you a defector if you wave to
them). I never saw the light of day there though, but it
is a factually accurate statment. McCain lives in the
shadowy world of factually accurate statements and
plausible deniability built into parsed words. Nice
work, if you can get it.

I believe I actually saw Waziristan from around Jalalabad
but I was most certainly not in the tribal region.
Certainly Tora Bora is visible, and I most certainly
did not nose around there.

McCain is either bending the truth or was surrounded
by an arsenal like he was in Baghdad several years
ago when he famously declared, helicopters above, three
rings of security, kevlar vest on that “look, Baghdad
is safe enough to walk around (with a batallion of
armed soldiers and sharp shooters guarding your every
step)”.

Nope. I don’t buy it.

Fact check!

by James Whitlow Delano | 01 Oct 2008 01:10 | Tokyo, Japan |
How John McCain Name-Dropped Waziristan and Misunderstood Pakistan

John McCain’s Pakistan-Waziristan Howlers

Did John McCain Visit Waziristan?

by Matt Wright-Steel | 01 Oct 2008 01:10 | Austin, Texas, United States |
Can’t they see Alaska and Arizona both from mountain peeks of Waziristan on a good day? ;)))))…….

and these peeps good god, which i guess, since im american are my peeps too, “represent” the “best and the brightest” and the “shining light of the free world”…

the worst thing too is that most of the electorate is going to think Waziristan is some kind of euphamism…

egads….

fingers crossed for a good outcome in november…

by Bob Black | 01 Oct 2008 12:10 (ed. Oct 1 2008) | Toronto, Canada |
hi all – thanks for the feedback. I’ve been told by a Pakistan -based journalist that McCain did indeed visit Waziristan, as part of a congressional delegation – helicoptered into the FATA by the Pakistani military. Unclear on when this happened, or if the delegation actually landed, or just flew over a piece of the terrain. At any rate, it sounds like he would have “been there” for a matter of minutes or hours.

by teru kuwayama | 01 Oct 2008 23:10 | NYC, United States |
Hi Teru,

That makes perfect sense.

Thanks.

Best,

James.

by James Whitlow Delano | 01 Oct 2008 23:10 | Tokyo, Japan |

Get notified when someone replies to this thread:
Feed-icon-10x10 via RSS
Recommended
Icon_email via email
You can unsubscribe later.

More about sponsorship→

Participants

teru kuwayama, teru kuwayama
NYC , United States
Daniele Mattioli, Photographer Daniele Mattioli
Photographer
(China Photographer)
Abu Dhabi , United Arab Emirates
En route to Shanghai, (ETA: Oct 16 2008).
Brian C Frank, Photojournalist | Photo R Brian C Frank
Photojournalist | Photo R
Des Moines, Iowa , United States
Thorne Anderson, Photojournalist Thorne Anderson
Photojournalist
Cambridge, Massachusetts , United States
James Whitlow Delano, James Whitlow Delano
Tokyo , Japan
Ramin Talaie, Akas Ramin Talaie
Akas
Brooklyn , United States
Matt Wright-Steel, Matt Wright-Steel
(Delusions of Grandeur)
Austin, Texas , United States
Bob Black, Suspect Photog/Writer Bob Black
Suspect Photog/Writer
(Dreamer- Archer-Husband-Dad)
New York City , United States


Keywords

Top↑ | RSS/XML | Privacy Statement | Terms of Use | support@lightstalkers.org / ©2004-2008 November Eleven